Hammondsport, NY

Baked
to Order.
Loved
from Day One.

Handcrafted bagels, made fresh every morning in the heart of the Southern Finger Lakes. No shortcuts. No compromises. Just dough, tradition, and fire.

Explore Our Bagels Find Us
Daily
Fresh Bakes
12+
Varieties
Est.
Hammondsport
Freshly baked bagels displayed on a wooden surface
Made with Love
Every single bagel
Scroll
Bagel dough being prepared by hand
Bagels baking in a traditional oven
Freshly baked bagels ready to serve
Interior of Brewer's Bagels shop
Our Story

A Tradition Rooted in
Southern Finger Lakes

Brewer's Bagels started with a simple conviction: that a bagel should taste like it was made by someone who actually cares. Located on Route 54 in the charming town of Hammondsport, we've been serving our neighbors with freshly baked bagels made from scratch every single morning.

Every bagel is hand-rolled, boiled, and baked using time-honored techniques passed down through generations. We source local ingredients whenever possible and never compromise on quality. From our classic plain to our seasonal specialties, each bagel carries the same commitment to craft.

Hand-Rolled
Every bagel shaped with care
Fresh Daily
Baked every morning at dawn
Local
Proudly Hammondsport-based
From Scratch
No shortcuts, ever
Our Products

Bagels Made the Right Way

From classic favorites to seasonal specialties, every bagel is crafted with the same dedication to quality and flavor.

Classic plain bagel with golden crust
Classic

Plain Bagel

Our signature bagel — a perfectly chewy interior with a crisp, golden crust. The foundation of every great breakfast.

Everything bagel with sesame and poppy seeds
Popular

Everything Bagel

Loaded with our proprietary spice blend — sesame, poppy, garlic, onion, and salt. The crowd favorite for a reason.

Cinnamon raisin bagel with visible spices
Sweet

Cinnamon Raisin

Warm cinnamon swirled through every bite, studded with plump raisins. Perfect for toast or with a pat of butter.

Seeded whole grain bagel
Hearty

Everything Seeds

A nutty, wholesome blend of flax, sunflower, and chia seeds on a dense, satisfying bagel. Packed with flavor and fiber.

Pretzel bagel with coarse salt
Savory

Garlic Pretzel

A pretzel-crusted bagel with roasted garlic and coarse salt. Bold, savory, and unlike anything you've tried before.

Seasonal specialty bagel
Seasonal

Seasonal Specialties

Rotating flavors that celebrate the seasons — from blueberry lavender in summer to maple bacon in fall. Ask about today's special.

* Contact us for current availability and pricing. Seasonal items rotate throughout the year.

The Process

From Dough to Your Hands

Every bagel goes through a meticulous process that takes time, skill, and patience — because great bagels can't be rushed.

01

Mix & Rest

Premium flour, water, and ingredients are blended and left to rest, developing flavor and structure naturally.

02

Shape by Hand

Each bagel is individually rolled and shaped by hand, ensuring the perfect ring and consistent texture.

03

Boil & Top

Briefly boiled for that signature chew, then topped with seeds, salts, or spices before baking.

04

Bake & Serve

Baked to golden perfection, then cooled and served the same day — never stale, always fresh.

Visit Us

Stop By & Try One

We're located right on Route 54 in the heart of Hammondsport. Pull in, say hello, and taste the difference that fresh-made makes.

Address
8471 NY-54
Hammondsport, NY 14840
Hours
Monday – Saturday: 6:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
Get in Touch

We'd Love to Hear from You

Have a question, want to place a bulk order, or just want to say hello? Drop us a message and we'll get back to you as soon as we can.

Is this your business?This is my business